Chronology Edit

In real-world chronology Miss Morgan was not the third, but fourth actress to play the part of Dr. Weir. That should be corrected in the character infobox in this article as well as in the actress' article. - Bell'Orso 09:59, 14 January 2009 (UTC)


Before I Sleep aired February 18, and it was her birthday in the episode. But... in Stargate SG-1: The DVD Collection 51 her birthday is stated as being in October. Just saying... as the Stargate Timeline is supposed to go with the "actual" one.—Anubis 10545 01:30, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Hum Edit

Maybe we could add that weir has a PH.D..... in Political sciences or international relations, just to explain why she is Dr. Weir instead of Madam Weir...

Death Edit

She did die when the nanites were removed from her body, the only thing keeping her alive. The nanites took her form and continued her "existence." This robot form was later destroyed when her group tried to ascend through cyberspace. -- Anythingspossibleforapossible (talk) (Contribs) 12:18, January 4, 2011 (UTC)

she obtained a new robot form upon de-ascending, which was never destroyed and continued to house the consciousness. there's the issue of whether the robot form and the human are the same individual, but the former certainly isn't dead or destroyed. ASDF1239 DISCUSSION 23:57, January 4, 2011 (UTC)
The human is dead despite what robot has taken her place. Only her consciousness has been kept alive which is purely artificial, containing her memories, which can hardly constitute a "living" status. -- Anythingspossibleforapossible (talk) (Contribs) 06:32, January 5, 2011 (UTC)

Hehe - let's not get into a philosophical debate here (even though I would agree with Anythingspossibleforapossible here, as even if Asurans were "alive", it would still be a different "brain" and a different peson, just with all the same memories). Nethertheless, the wiki has no separate articles for Wier's different "forms", and it also includes Michele Morgan (FRAN) as playing Wier, so we can assume that this wiki regards them as all being the same person. Therefore, saying she died when her first body died would make the article confusing. Perhaps multiple dates of death are required :D Sman789 (talk) (Contribs) 09:03, January 5, 2011 (UTC)

Actually - forget what I just said! RepliCARTER has a seperate article and is considered a different person from normal Carter, and the Altairan android versions of the SG-1 team have seperate articles. For this reason, I propose that we split Weir's article into "Elizabeth Weir" and then another article called "Elizabeth Weir (Asuran)". We can probably treat all three of her Asuran forms as being the same person, though, for the sake of simplicity and because we don't just want three tiny stub articles :) Sman789 (talk) (Contribs) 09:09, January 5, 2011 (UTC)
i concur ASDF1239 DISCUSSION 21:32, January 5, 2011 (UTC)
I concur to his concurance. Jauh0 (talk) (Contribs) 10:37, January 6, 2011 (UTC)

The problem with this whole discussion is that we don't even know if the original Weir is really dead. RepliKeller never provided any proof to back up her claim that Oberoth killed the original Weir, and as pointed out in the article, Joe Mallozzi himself proposed that the Replicators studying ascension had plenty of motivation to lie in order to keep Atlantis from finding out the original Weir might still be alive. The same goes for "Weir" in FRAN's body in "Ghost in the Machine." She claimed to have memories of being the original Weir and being turned into a full Replicator on Asuras, but she offered no proof that those memories were real. Remember, we are talking about the Replicators, masters of sticking their hands in people's heads and screwing with their minds. It would've been a piece of cake for them to create a set of false memories and implant them in the body of yet another duplicate of Weir, for whatever purpose they intended to use her for: to study in a controlled experiment, to further muddle the trail so that Atlantis couldn't find the real Weir, or something else. I suggest that the death dates listed under Weir's biographical information be removed, as no body or any other conclusive proof that she is dead has ever been found, and that her current status be changed to "missing in action," with perhaps a further clarification that there have been reports of her death that have not been independently confirmed by Atlantis/Earth personnel. It's the most accurate and neutral option based on available evidence. 06:43, March 11, 2011 (UTC)

Wrong Word Edit

In the 2004 section, third paragraph in, roughly halfway down it says, "With a catastrophic failure emanate..." It should read, "With a catastrophic failure imminent..." 11:40, July 10, 2012 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.