Talk:K'tau

This episode is utter bull. I do not meen to be offensive, but there is so much wrong with it from a scientific standpoint.

1. The time it takes for a star's core to change the coloration of the photosphere is hundreds of years, the density of the plasma means that a star's color doesn't shift unless it began to expand thus cooling the plasma on the surface.

2. There is no such thing as a stable superheavy element. Any and all superheavy elements have an excess amount of neutrons resulting in them being radioactive and unstable.

3. If this is such a big problem how come stargates just redirect the extra dimentional wormhole around stars instead of through them? How is it even so precies as to cause the wormhole to go through the star's core? Even if the wormhole is as big as a star it would be like throwing a needle through the eye of another needle if you were in San Diego and and the other needle was in New York on a taxi going around the city.

4. A rocket would not be able to get any kind of element into the star's core since the core is millions of miles inside the star covered in plasma that would surely melt the rocket into an amorphous blob of star poison.

5. Iron is just as effective at slowing down the nuclear reaction inside a star as any other element. And even then it would take a lot of iron just to slow it enough to cause a dramatic change.

6. Not to mention there would be no build up of material until the star's fusion had naturally reached that level. A star will not die just because you introduce a higher-than-iron element into the reaction. Otherwise the naquadah of the stargates would surely cause this problem too if not the iron in the blood of humans and metal tools passing through the stargate.

7. Why didn't the other multiple trips to assemble the rocket also shorten the time it takes for the eye of odin to go out?

8. And if it did, where is this plutonium coming from anyways?

9. The Asgard didn't even include some safety measure to protect the K'tau people like Thor's Hammer.

10. Plants grow better in red light because they can better absorb that spectrum in their leaves. The plant life would not have died off just because the star became red.

11. How did they dial back to Earth? Wouldn't the DHD on K'tau have prevented it? And if they traveled to another planet first to go back to earth, why didn't they do that in the first place instead of ignoring Stargate protocols?

12. Why do the K'tau people have a direct link to the Asgard instead of the test system like Thor's hall of wisdom? Why don't the SGC have a direct link to the Asgard who are their allies?

13. The stargate passing through a star is not a natural event, it would not violate the Protected Planet's Treaty to fix the star. And even if it did how would the goa'uld know? Do the Asgard inform them of information on the protected planets?

14. Are the Asgard just so bad at legal understanding that they didn't include a loophole in their own treaty that would give them the opportunity to interfere to allow species survival? Not to mention what if this definition of interfere? If it is soley to not interefere with their evolution as a society and people, then they already violated that by posing as their gods. If they mean genetic evolution (personally I don't believe but that's beside these points) then how would fixing a star change anything about that?

Cruaver, Lord of Logic (talk) (Contribs) 20:20, April 11, 2016 (UTC)